Thank you all for such nice comments on yesterday's kitchen reveal! We're pleased with it, but it's even better to hear that other people think it looks great too, because it was a lot of work not only to do the projects but also to pick out all the materials in the first place. I started
pinning inspirations and researching materials months before we got contractor estimates (Angie's list all the way!), but having never done this before it was hard to make what felt like such big decisions on everything.
Now that it's done, here are some detail shots along with all the sources and some comments about the materials and accessories I ended up choosing (and repurposing in a few cases). It gets wordy, so read if you want kitchen tips; scroll if you want pretty pictures.
Tile: all of the inspiration photos I bookmarked had subway tile backsplashes, so that was a no-brainer. We just went with the Lowe's version for about 21 cents per tile.
Flooring: since we have two doorways with the original wood flooring leading into the kitchen, I wanted to avoid a wood look that might clash and decided on something slate colored. Eventually I discovered these vinyl tiles at a flooring center - they're warmer and softer (i.e. when you drop dishes) than actual tiles, and while the price per square foot was comparable, we ended up saving money because it was installed directly over the old tile (not the original plan; long story, the main points of which are (1) the existing tile was installed to withstand the end times and (2) we discovered that someone put that gross tile over the original hardwoods - gah!).
Counters: when choosing a material for the counter tops, I thought partly about value and about preference - granite seems to be default, but I don't love it, and I don't think the resale value is quite there in our neighborhood. So I thought the butcher block alternative would bring a nice warmth and look good with the style and age of the rest of the house, plus it was really a bargain from Ikea. One of my favorite things about it is how the contractor was able to extend the counter the weird curved shelves on one side of the kitchen - it adds about an extra foot of counter space, plus it makes things look more finished.
Sink: the previous stainless steel sink we had was showing a bit of wear with scratches and burn marks, so I thought if everything else was going to be shiny and new, we might as well pick up a new one since it was fairly inexpensive from Lowe's. Faucets are shockingly expensive though, so we just reused that - though the contractor replaced the icky sprayer nozzle, which makes a big difference.
Dishwasher: the old one was going to need replacing at some point, so this was obviously the time to do it. As a bonus, since we got replacements of the stove and microwave for Christmas last year, we now have all matching appliances.

Knobs/
handles: with the cabinet refresh cabinets, I definitely wanted to do some new hardware too - I was thinking a cup pull on the drawers, and the not-quite-standard hole spacing on our drawers helped narrow down my selections greatly. I found these online with a coupon and then selected a coordinating knob from the same company.
Curtain fabric: the faux roman shade is a
DIY from a while ago. I still love this chipper print fabric, so I definitely wanted to re-use the shade, so I picked the accent color scheme from there.
Rug: temptations to get all new accent pieces and accessories are great when you're looking at an overhauled kitchen, and I gave in on the rug, brought home on post-Thanksgiving sale from Crate & Barrel. I put it down just for a trial in the photos, but I think it's a keeper - I've always loved these striped rugs, and the gold color is kind of fun.
Paint: we used Behr paint from Home Depot in a semi-gloss since we've seen it rated very well by Consumer Reports in the past; I chose
picket fence (cabinets) and
sharkey gray (walls) from the Martha Stewart line and had them color matched to the paint.


Oven mitt: sometimes the Vera Bradley store likes to send me $20 off coupons, so I picked up a new pot holder set in coordinating colors for a steal.
Canisters: these are just inexpensive jars from Hobby Lobby that were in my craft center - I thought they would be nice for display on the corner shelf, so now they're repurposed to hold Ginger's treats and Peter's candy.
Art: most of the art around the house was made by some family member or family connection of mine (they're a creative bunch), and practically everything was matted and framed by my grandma. This is one of her pieces.
Fruit bowl: and another little something new I couldn't resist at Crate & Barrel - it's perfect on the counter or the side shelves.
Soap: this was our kitchen soap before the renovation, and now it looks even more perfect in here. I already can't resist Method soaps' cute packaging and nice scents, so when the Orla Kiely designed ones showed up at Target, a couple patterns came home with me.