Nothing new under the sun? Or tales that are for all of time? No matter your take, there seem to be lots of modern-day re-settings of classic stories lately, and I have picked up several of them. The trick with a retelling is that on the one hand, it can bring to life in a new and delightful way a favorite story - but on the other hand, it can also be majorly disappointing if it doesn't live up to expectations of beloved characters and scenes. These reviews definitely represent that mixed bag...
Ayesha at Last
I am a sucker for any thing Jane Austen, especially a
Pride & Prejudice retelling, so I was excited to pick this one up, at last... but I feel a little led astray by the Modern Mrs. Darcy blog on this one. I think that the setting of an Indian Muslim community in Toronto is definitely an interesting way to go for a modern-day setting (the cultural ideas of chastity, modesty, potential arranged marriages make so much more sense with the Austen era focus on a woman
needing to marry, and also needing to marry "well"), and I found the idea of making the Darcy character a very conservative religious person an interesting way to explore prejudice - the first time she sees him, Ayesha immediately pegs him as a fundamentalist she could never get along with, and conversely he imagines her as sort of a "loose" woman because she's at a place where others are ordering alcohol. But I just couldn't feel a spark in their interactions, or a love for these characters (Ayesha felt so wishy-washy, not independent Lizzie Bennett-ish, at times) that made me all that invested in their happy ending, as I am SO invested in even still when I read/watch the Austen P&P for the millionth time. Also, while I do think a retelling like this can still be good/interesting even with some change-ups (like
Pride, Prejudice & Other Flavors switching the Darcy figure to a female character, and vice versa with the Elizabeth figure), I thought this one was just too muddied - there was this whole extra mistaken identity side plot that felt unnecessary and distracting, and some of the characters' actions seemed much more mean-spirited. All in all, not my favorite entry in this category.
2.5/5 stars
Of Curses & Kisses
This re-setting of Beauty and the Beast takes place at an elite boarding school nestled in the mountains of Colorado, where the wealthy and the noble from around the world send their kids - and where Princess Jaya Rao and her younger sister arrive from India after a media scandal that Jaya thinks was set up by the youngest heir of her family's longstanding enemy, the Emerson family of British aristocracy. She's determined to get her revenge by tricking the Emerson heir into falling in love with her and then breaking his heart. Instead of a literal beast, in this retelling, we have broody misanthrope Grey Emerson, who has been told since he was very young that he is the focus of a curse put on the family many years ago by an angry Rao, and he believes the old prophesy that the family line ends with him at his 18th birthday. Of course, fitting with the fairy tale, as they slowly get to know each other, they find the person beneath to be someone entirely different than they expected... While I didn't love it as much, it did give me a little satisfaction in the
American Royals-shaped hole in my life, with the teenaged royalty/nobility and their antics along with their sense of duty conflicting with their personal dreams; also reminded me a little of books that involve boarding school with unique students/storied family history, like
A Study in Charlotte (modern-day Sherlock Holmes retelling) and
Truly Devious. And of course there's the comparison with
A Curse So Dark and Lonely, given the same fairy tale focus. This was fun, and I'm definitely curious to see what is planned for book 2 in this series, but I'm clamoring more for the sequels to
American Royals and
A Curse So Dark and Lonely, perhaps because their characters gave me a little more of the swoony feels I want from this YA category, and not enough of the spark of the characters I adore from
this author's other (excellent) books.
(Releases February 18; I received an e-copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.) 3.5/5 stars
A Curse So Dark and Lonely
Another (very popular - I'm behind the times, I know) retelling of Beauty and the Beast; in this one Prince Rhen of Emberfall has been cursed by a vengeful enchantress to repeat the fall of his 18th year over and over until the curse is broken, and at the end of each season he turns into a terrible, lethal beast, imperiling his whole family and his citizens. By the time we meet him, his family are all dead along with many townspeople, and he has holed up in the castle in the name of protecting those who remain - except that meanwhile his citizens are suffering from poverty and threats from outside warring kingdoms. He still has his broody and dutiful (but oh so swoony) bodyguard Grey at his side though, who goes each season to retrieve a girl from "the other side" (aka Washington DC) to try to break the curse with. Only this time, he hasn't gotten the docile material he expected when he snatches Harper, a scrappy teen who is frequently getting underestimated because of her cerebral palsy. She is not going to be the damsel in distress or the fall in love with a prince type - she's independent and principled but also very caring, which means she really understands what's at stake, that it's going to take more than just breaking Rhen's curse to save his kingdom. I'm not usually into fantasy that requires "world building", but this one was grounded in the real world, so that helped - and it was interesting to see a real world character interact with a fantasy world that she had no idea existed. If I was confused at times (and I was) about the parameters of this fantasy world, it sort of made sense to be gradually learning the details alongside Harper who was also new to it. I really hated the witchy character, Lilith, who cursed Rhen, partly because she's so sadistic and awful, but partly because her powers make it seem like there's no way for the good guys to ever win, and that's kind of exhausting to me as a reader. Still looking forward to checking out the next in the series though, which was just published.
3.5/5 stars
Meg and Jo
This modern-day retelling of
Little Women sets the March family in small-town North Carolina and tells the adulthood part of the sisters' story from the perspectives of Jo (cast as a laid-off newspaper reporter turned food blogger) and Meg (a stay-at-home mom of twins who still lives in their hometown). While Meg seems to have the life she's always wanted, with the house and the husband and kids, she's struggling a bit behind the scenes to juggle it all, especially when their mother starts needing more help around the farm, given ailing health. And Jo's return home to the family farm comes with the baggage of a breakup and dashed aspirations of making it as a writer in New York.
I am still obsessed with the new
Greta Gerwig movie adaptation after seeing it in December, so I was up for trying out any type of retelling right now, and was also ready for a timeline that focuses mostly on adulthood with just flashbacks to or brief mentions of the classic episodes of the hair singing, book burning, near-drowning of Amy, etc. I think this is smart in some ways because it allows the reader to open up their minds a bit to modern-day, adult characters, without having to try to stretch all of the story to fit exactly a contemporary setting. I did miss a bit how having the sisters grown up and living apart doesn't give you quite as much a sense of their bond - you don't think of them as quite the "March sisters" unit. I'd consider this a fairly fluffy chick lit type of read, with okay writing, but still had quite a bit of fun reading it because of the love I have for the original characters. Especially loved the Jo romance storyline in this one - a modern day setting means we can add (a little) steam!
3.5/5 stars
The Dead Queens Club
Henry the VIII is recast as Henry is the most popular kid in Lancaster High - he's super smart, he's also the star of the football team, he's about to be crowned prom king, and he has this magnetic energy that draws everyone to him. Our narrator Cleves meets him at "overachiever" camp one summer, and they instantly become best of friends, which means that when she moves to his town, she enters her senior year in the cool group, high school "royalty", by association. Of course Cleves has a thing for him (how could she not?), but Henry is on his 6th girlfriend in 2 years. And the girlfriends that he has dumped? Kiss of death to their reputations - except that 2 of the girlfriends actually wind up literally dead, one in a freak prom explosion that happened the year before Cleves moved to town. There are tons of rumors and theories among their classmates, but Cleves is determined to get to the bottom of it, which turns it into a bit of a girl power tale, as she joins up with some of the earlier girlfriends to investigate. A bit like YA school-based whodunit mysteries like
One of Us Is Lying and
Truly Devious, but with the historical retelling twist - which was fun, but sometimes made it feel overly like a stretch in terms of characters' motivations and actions. It was a little contrived or hard to follow at times, but if you're craving a YA mystery with snappy dialogue and a bit of outrageous high school action (this is not the gritty kind of YA like
Sadie, it's the romp around kind with intrigue added in), or if you enjoy history from the era of Henry VIII and want to see how many little details/names are cleverly worked in to a modern scenario, give it a go!
3/5 stars
Seems like YA is a great category for taking on retellings of this sort, as you can see from 3 of the 5 on this list, and of course
Pride & Prejudice has got to be the most re-told tale in all the classics... I've always loved
Bridget Jones' Diary, and while it wasn't popular with everyone, I really enjoyed
Eligible, partly because I lived in Cincinnati and loved those connections. Still on my list to read is
Pride, which is both YA
and P&P!
Sharing on Show Us Your Books.