Okay, here's a fun little reading roundup for your summer lists: a few escapist mysteries I've read lately that are great to get lost in (and finish in a day, in some cases!) but will also make you stop and think a bit about motherhood and marriage, thanks to the moms doing the investigating in them. For all three of these it might be best not knowing too much going in, so that you can just go along for the ride - so I'll try to minimize the plot summaries and just share what I liked about them... the long and short of it is, add them to your list!
Mother May I
Joshilyn Jackson has long been an auto-buy (pre-order!) author for me, and much as I enjoy her earlier work, I love how her last book, Never Have I Ever, took a turn into more of a (lite) thriller genre. Her newest follows in this vein, and with its excellent characters, and even more excellent twists and turns (the kind that are intriguing, surprising, and satisfying) I think it is my new favorite of all. I barely knew anything about the plot going in (like I said, auto-buy) and I think that was a good way to go, so I won't say much but the barest of bones: Bree grew up poor and a bit distrustful of the world thanks to her mother's warnings that the world is a scary place, but as a mother of two lovely pre-teen daughters and a delightful baby son, the wife of a successful lawyer, and a lady who has it all put-together with her lovely suburban home in a good neighborhood, all seems right with the world. Until one morning she wakes up and thinks she sees a witch - and soon her baby boy has disappeared, and we're on a race-against-the-clock ride with Bree that will upend her whole understanding of her marriage and life. This one reads a bit as a legal thriller thanks to the help Bree gets from an investigator for her husband's law firm and an old friend, and I
do love that genre, so that was a boon on top of the twisty, fast-paced plot. I also love how Jackson writes down-to-earth protagonists who I root for. They might be unreliable narrators insofar as they see the situation from only their own perspective, or they might have a secret from their past that we are unraveling, but they feel like real women who we can really understand and root for (also appreciate how at their core their current family relationships are loving - some great mother/child relationships - even if the mom is facing some skeletons in the closet), which sets them apart from (above!) other thrillers for me. Here I came for the juicy, twisty reading, but I stayed for the insights on motherhood - the nature of the relationship and how it binds women together, what moms will do for their children, and so on. The story also delves into issues of class, privilege, sexual abuse, and how people should be accountable for their past/younger decisions (and for how long, a bit of a #MeToo edge) in thought-provoking ways while still moving along at a finish-in-one-day clip.
4.5/5 stars, a thriller that left me thinking... after I caught my breath
Finlay Donovan Is Killing It
I'm not entirely sure how to categorize this book - it's not exactly a thriller in the way you might generally think of one - but I can say for sure that it was fun. It feels a bit like "mommy fiction" in that you've got this frazzled single mom trying to make ends meet while she faces writer's block, an unfaithful husband, messy toddlers, and no childcare and you get all the satire to go along with that - but then it turns into this comedic murder mystery (almost slapstick at times, but not over the top) that has some very unexpected twists when Finlay, meeting with her editor in a suburban Panera to talk about her idea for a new suspense novel, gets overheard and mistaken for being a contract killer. Before she knows it there's a dead body in the back of her minivan that she's got to figure out how to get rid of... It's almost the book version of the Netflix show Dead to Me (the book would totally make a great TV series too), in the relationships Finlay has and also the way you constantly think that she's going to run into a dead end or get discovered but then something unexpected has everyone breathing a sigh of relief. A witty, fast-paced, and fun ride for sure that could be enjoyed by many people, but then as a mom of a young kid I thought some of the observations about all the things that a mom juggles, the paradoxical love and total boredom with her kids that she can feel, etc. were very funny, relatable, and even thought-provoking - so I enjoyed this extra layer. Plus I loved that she is an author, and you get tidbits on the publishing world, kind of a meta feel when she's writing suspense and starring in it, as well. Overall a total change of pace that would make for excellent beach reading.
4/5 stars, making comedic mystery totally work (I might have had my doubts), and I will totally pick up the forthcoming sequel
The Last Thing He Told Me
Hannah's husband Owen hasn't come home, but she's received a note in his writing: Protect her. She knows immediately that he means his 16-year-old daughter, Bailey, even if she has no idea where or why he's disappeared. As US marshals and FBI agents show up to question her about Owen's whereabouts, and as news of a major scandal + arrests at the startup firm where Owen works starts being reported, it starts to dawn on her that Owen is not who he said he was. Still, Hannah makes it her mission to indeed to make Bailey the #1 priority on his behalf - but also to uncover why Owen has disappeared...before the feds do. I loved the vivid settings (especially their Sausalito houseboat home), the strong lead character, the hands-on amateur investigation Hannah and Bailey undertake, and how the flashback moments start to unravel the mystery for the reader and for Hannah at the same time as she looks at past conversations with Owen in a new light. The mother relationship is a bit different in this one, as it is a stepmother who has a teen actively resisting a relationship - and suddenly finds herself having to figure out how to be that teen's only remaining parent, and how to balance her own feelings of loss - missing the love of her life and also grappling with him maybe not being who she thought - with making sure that the well-being of his daughter is top priority. The fake identity and lying husband plot make for some great twists and turns, and the chosen family theme brings it home as a thriller that can make you think a bit deeper, beyond just being entertained.
4/5 stars, a short and tightly woven puzzle of a story - successful May BOTM club pick!
For some more mysteries/thrillers starring suburban moms that will give you the drama and juicy twists but also some relatable insights, I also love: Joshilyn Jackson's Never Have I Ever, Aimee Molloy's The Perfect Mother, Jessica Strawser's Not That I Could Tell, and Laura Hankin's Happy & You Know It (more of a comedic one; the others are more like Mother May I and The Last Thing He Told Me).
Sharing on Show Us Your Books.