Reading 100+ books per year, I find it pretty hard to narrow down to a "best of" list, so I typically try to break it down into categories and pick my 2 top ones in each. And every year I seem to find that I need to break down my categories even further, so that I can squeeze in some more mentions of books I loved. So this is a pretty long list, but for the record, here is my (somewhat stingy/arbitrary, I know!) list of 5-star books for the year (but I've got plenty of 4.5-ers below): 84 Charing Cross Road, The Duchess of Bloomsbury Street, Nobody Will Tell You This but Me, The Poet X, and Mother May I.

Though we're obviously not quite to the end of the year, I thought I'd go ahead and post my list now as I'm not sure these will be topped in the next week or so - and also because if you've got some time off over the holidays, or maybe even receive some bookstore giftcard presents (wooo!), you can't go wrong with picking up one of these great reads. (You can also check out my top picks for the last couple of years too, because there are some good ones there that I still find myself recommending over and over!
2020 /
2019.)
And do tell if you've read/enjoyed any of these, and/or hit me with your best books of the year so I can start thinking about my 2022 reading priorities!
Literary fiction
What Comes After: great combination of character-driven, following two parents in their grief and a young woman in her loneliness, and plot-driven, as we unravel what led to a murder-suicide of a teen and his friend. Sounds dark, and there are certainly some very heavy moments, but ultimately connection and hope and forgiveness too (
full review).
A Children's Bible: this story has lots going on, with an apocalyptic/climate change storyline, but also read to me as coming-of-age, allegory, and a bit of satire as well. A bit of a weird one, but very interesting and well-written, and I still can't stop thinking about it (full review).
Contemporary fiction
Early Morning Riser: quirky cast of characters and overall big-hearted tone with the unconventional/found-family aspect, as we basically just follow their small-town lives and relationships over the course of several years, but not too light/fluffy/zany. Plus I loved the small-town Michigan setting!
Under the Rainbow: reads as a series of connected short stories about LGBTQ activist group coming to work in the town voted most homophobic in America. Comes together really nicely, got me thinking about multiple perspectives, and brought a hopeful tone to this real-world area of acrimony in the US (full review).
Historical fiction
The Song of Achilles: retells the story of Achilles through the perspective of his friend (lover) Patrocles. Both a coming-of-age and love story, super well done and engrossing (
full review).
Outlawed: a bit of an alternate reality history in a Wild West of a US that is dominated by religion that prizes female fertility - so this is the story of the outlaws who don't fit that mold because they are barren, gender nonconforming, etc. So much food for thought combined with a gender-bending Western complete with nail-biting shoot-out scenes (full review).
Romance/rom-com
The Soulmate Equation: well-developed characters who are facing some struggles but have great banter/some comedic moments, and a great twist on tropes I love - enemies to lovers, with a dash of fake dating, but the backdrop of the story is a new dating app that matches people based on genetic markers, to predict their compatibility (
full review).
Very Sincerely Yours: a light and very tame romance for those who want a sweet story without too much hot'n'heavy action, with a woman trying to find her purpose in life having a meet-cute with Everett St. James, a very cute Mr. Rogers-like figure, who maybe needs her help letting go a little of his single-minded focus on his children's tv show. Very cute, great banter.
Mystery/thriller
Mother May I: family drama with twists and turns that are so satisfying - but also makes you really think about motherhood, what past mistakes might be forgivable in a relationship (bit of a #MeToo edge), and what parents are willing to do for their children. A read-in-one-day book for me (
full review).
The Survivors: Jane Harper does it again with a slow-burn, atmospheric, family-drama mystery that is enhanced by another Australian setting, this time a small, windswept coastal town where past tragedy is resurfacing in light of a new one (full review).
Nonfiction
Nobody Will Tell You This but Me: Bess Kalb's memoir of her relationship with her grandmother who has recently passed away - told from her grandmother's witty, zingy perspective. Will make you laugh and cry and take away some great life lessons from this impressive and feisty lady. (
full review)
The Duchess of Bloomsbury Street: must read Helene Hanff's memoir-in-letters first; this follow-up is the journal of the trip she finally gets to take to the bookshop in London she has been corresponding with for years. It is a *delight* and some pretty great armchair travel too (full review).
Backlist
Girl, Woman, Other: through interconnected (short) stories of individual women we get a picture of the range of British Black female (or non-binary) experience and opportunities (or lack of), from country of origin/first or second generation immigrant experience, social class, sexual orientation, to political persuasion and more. Poetic writing in the best of ways, and powerful stories (
full review).
The Poet X: I have enjoyed all of Elizazbeth Acevedo's recent books so finally went back to her first, a YA novel-in-verse about a Latina girl who is just "too" everything and is trying to find her voice and space in the world, and I think it is her best work of all! Very powerful and gorgeously written (full review).
YA
Firekeeper's Daughter: has standard YA feels with the friendship/romantic interest/starting college aspects, but also it's a mystery, a sports book (lots of hockey), an exploration of a Native American culture (which also gives it a very strong sense of place), and even an exploration of what opioid/meth epidemics are doing to communities. Really enjoyed what all this combination meant for the character development and the plot (
full review).
Tokyo Ever After: when you just want a Princess Diaries/American Royals/Crazy Rich Asians-lite escape... so satisfying on all these counts, I couldn't put it down. (full review).
Middle grade
El Deafo: a graphic novel that Peter, Hendrik, and I all enjoyed equally. Tells the story of the author's experiences with major hearing loss early in life, and how she turned this difficulty into her "superpower." Illustrations are delightful!
Winterhouse: a bookish, wordplay-loving girl is sent alone by her mean aunt & uncle to the Winterhouse Hotel for Christmas break - which turns out to be a delightful place with new friends, but also with a strange family mystery and maybe some magic too... A great holiday break read. Fun, bookish, found family vibes - and part of a series, so I'm excited to get to spend more time at this hotel that I wish were a real-life place!
Shop them all here, plus a few bonus picks:
Sharing on Show Us Your Books.