When I sat down to compile my May reads, I was surprised at how many books I got through this month - almost forgot about some of them! The numbers were upped by having done 3 audiobooks (a huge number for me in this span of time), and maybe a couple of books that I wasn't super loving, so I read them kinda fast. I had a mix of new books from top-favorite authors - though not my favorite from them for the most part, unfortunately - and some exciting new finds too.
Literary/contemporary fiction
How to Commit a Postcolonial Murder: 1986 was a big year - the Challenger disaster, the return of Halley's Comet, the Chernobyl disaster, the televised wedding of Prince Andrew and Sarah Ferguson. And as she experiences these things from her home in small-town Wyoming, Georgie also experiences major upheaval in her life: her uncle, aunt, and cousin come from India to move in with Georgie, her parents, and her older sister Agatha. They try to be welcoming, as family does, until Agatha decides that it is time for her uncle to go - and she and Georgie are going to take care of it.
We soon learn that the reason for this is incredibly sad and difficult: they see no other way to escape his abuse. But Georgie's narration, making their "case" and telling about the months leading up to/following their uncle's death, is both cheeky and sardonic, sometimes directly addressing the (white) reader and confronting their assumptions about immigrants and Indians (vs the other "Indians" - Native Americans) and their experience, and also interspersed with teen magazine-like quizzes that bring up all of the conflicting emotions Georgie faces regarding her crumbling relationship with her sister and her guilt about her uncle. I feel like the end of the blurb captures really well the genre mash-up, the themes, the darkly comedic approach, and Georgie's general tone/voice: "At its heart, the tale she weaves is: a) a vivid portrait of an extended family; b) a moving story of sisterhood; c) a playful ode to the 80s; d) a murder mystery (of sorts); e) an unexpected and unwaveringly powerful meditation on history and language, trauma and healing, and the meaning of independence. Or maybe it’s really: f) all of the above."
There were some parts where the timeline felt a tad confusing, but overall I found this such a refreshing read, dealing with something really sad and difficult but in a unique way, involving both dark humor and deep empathy. The way Georgie talks about sexual abuse by a family member is not graphic, but it is heart-wrenching in the emotional and physical pain, and in how terrible it must be to feel that silence is the only option - until Agatha comes up with a permanent solution, that is. It's a short read and worth it if you can read it in that spirit (I've seen other reviews on Goodreads that maybe tried to read it more "straight", and those readers didn't like it...). There are tons of themes to ponder beyond this too - racism, prejudice/bias, colonialism, privilege, family bonds, healing, and more... Made me think of some of the themes in
Good People as well, though this is much more of a dark comedy approach.
★★★★.25
Evensong: In this character driven, quiet, and quotidian novel, Stewart O'Nan revisits some characters from earlier works (most notably Emily Maxwell and her sister-in-law Arlene from
Emily, Alone and
Wish You Were Here) in the post-covid years. This group of women-of-a-certain-age who attend the same Pittsburgh church are also part of a group they call the Humpty Dumpty Club, which is organized around helping other aging people with whatever care/tasks they might need, like rides to a doctor's office, picking up prescriptions, etc. Four of the most prominent members have to pick up some slack when their indominable leader, Joan, has a fall and requires rehab in a nursing home, and the book follows them through a year as they care for others in their community, as they become closer as friends, and as they also face their own challenges with aging
The book has an intimate feel because of how it portrays the minutia of their lives as aging/widowed/divorced women, but also how well it evokes the real feelings that can come with that stage of life, from regrets about rifts with their children to fear/denial about the onset of dementia, to the indignities of how loss of abilities requires relying on others and the feeling of being at the margin of society and perhaps not having anything useful to offer. This gives it a bit of a melancholy feel, but the women and their foibles and idiosyncrasies still give it levity, and overall there is a feeling of hope and warmth thanks to community and care, both of which give meaning to life in spite of its difficulties (whether major or minor).
If you are looking for a book/a fastidious character that feels like
The Correspondent, I definitely suggest
Emily, Alone (a 5-star read as well) - but also
Evensong has similar themes and considerations and overall episodic and so very human feel to it. Also would suggest for fans of
Elizabeth Strout, especially her
Olive Kitteridge character. It was sometimes a bit confusing which character was being referenced as each chapter often jumped among them rather than focusing on one character, and having several protagonists doesn't allow you such a close feeling to any one character, so that maybe prevented me from loving it 100%, but overall it was still a book that I wanted to give a melancholy yet contented hug when I finished. The end is so poignant and overall it is just so human, and I loved the use of Evensong as the title/metaphor for this twilight time of life, in parallel to the evensong services of certain church traditions, which provide a reflective and meditative end-of-day worship time (and of course the church-going ladies in this book attend these services too).
★★★★.5
American Fantasy: With the bubble-gum cover and the tagline about "what happens when your teenage fantasy becomes reality as an adult", Emma Straub's newest book, about a 50-year-old woman who goes on a cruise featuring performances by and meet-and-greets with the 1990s boyband obsession of her youth, sure seems like it should be frothy fun... but I think the marketing of this one leads to disappointment in the reading experience. It's not a rom-com by any means, nor is it simply a romp about a woman finding herself via her past as I was led to believe in the blurb. Instead, it's more of a character study of 3 different people - Annie, the divorcee who reluctantly goes on this cruise full of rabid fans; Keith, one of the Boy Talk members, who loves the singing but is super drained by the whole being "on" part of fame, especially when it comes to a cruise where he can't escape the fawning fans; and Sarah, a 30-year-old cruise line employee tasked with wrangling the band members and making sure all of the planned performances and appearances go smoothly yet preoccupied with following the social media accounts of the girl she just got dumped for - and of how these people face a kind of "how did my life turn out to be this" situation. At different ages/stages all three of them are confronted on this cruise, sometimes in a bit comedic of ways (which is how the overall tone stays light), with how their regular lives are not working for them, and figuring out how to take back the reins in their lives and pursue their own happiness.
I love Emma Straub's writing and the way she captures an ensemble cast and makes such wry and true observations about the foibles and flaws of modern life/humanity/relationships - but also infuses it all with big-heartedness - but this one just did not work as well for me as her previous books. I think it's partly because the ensemble cast in this case is a bit disparate - unlike in something like All Adults Here, where it's a group of grown siblings who all have their own lives and concerns but converge in the family home, this book's protagonists are 3 different characters who barely intersect in terms of plot/interactions, so it just feels like there's too much going on... yet at the same time, nothing's happening. (Seriously, especially the beginning - so slow!) A bit disappointing, but still worth a read if you are interested in tapping into some feelings of nostalgia, or exploring a bit what it would be like to be a 50-something whose heyday was as a teen idol, and what that does to the psyche. I did like the themes/reflections on youth and aging, fame and fandom, nostalgia and starting anew - but the delivery just fell a bit flat with how slow things moved and how many characters were involved. (Such as the advertised "befriending of a band member" from the blurb - there isn't even a hint of anything along these lines happening until more than halfway through the book.)
★★★.25
Porcupines: Sonia is a single mom who stays at a remove from other parents (while having plenty of internal sassy commentary about suburban PTA moms); she is always prickly and vague about her personal life/family history and instructs her tween daughter, Mila, to act the same - until Sonia is forced into proximity with parents and students alike when Mila surreptitiously signs her up to chaperone a school orchestra trip to San Francisco. The orchestra trip, the follies that happen along the way, and Sonia's snarky attitude about it all are interspersed with chapters about Sonia's upbringing in Cold War-era Budapest, to her immigration to the US as a teen, and her unexpected pregnancy. These chapters slowly reveal the reasons Sonia has for concealing her past, all while the walls she has built are coming crashing down thanks to some "who is my dad?" sleuthing by Mila.
I like a snarky and singular narrative voice, but at times this one felt like it was trying a little *too* hard - sometimes I had to go back and re-read sentences because the actual meaning of it could get lost within the snarky observational comparison. And I think the way Sonia's character is developed is done in part to demonstrate the lack of connection that can come from being an immigrant (especially an undocumented one), but that doesn't really make for an enjoyable reading experience for me as I feel completely held at remove from the characters too. To add to that, while the sections set in Sonia's past felt like a character exploration that included delving into soviet-era upbringing and Jewish family history, the present-day ones felt more like a madcap comedy of errors slash PTA mom send-up. That type of zaniness can make me feel disconnected from characters sometimes, and also it just didn't mesh with the rest of the book in some ways.
After finishing, I was reading through some Goodreads reviews to try to make sense of the ambivalence I was feeling - appreciating parts of the message but finding that the reading experience was meh. I saw these comments in a review from user Greg and thought they were very helpful/illustrative: "Rather than driving forward on an engaging plot, Fabriczki seems to build a kind of emotional anthropology. Viewed this way, one can be more generous. Its slowness can be viewed as a reflection of Sonia’s own dislocation: immigration, generational tension, and identity aren’t experienced as neat arcs but as long stretches of uncertainty punctuated by small, often ambiguous encounters. It may seem to cohere more if one approaches it as a study of friction—between cultures, and between mothers and daughters.... Her struggles with her daughter, mother, and sister aren’t framed as problems to be solved but as tensions she must endure. This has an unsatisfying feel, but it also resists the kind of tidy resolutions the novel seems to want to avoid."
★★★
Mystery/thriller
Last One Out: Five years ago, Ro's son Sam went out to interview some fellow townspeople for his oral history thesis project, preserving memories of their rural Australian town that had been slowly crumbling away as a mining company set up operations and took over land, but that evening he didn't show up at home for his 21st birthday dinner, and he was never seen again. In the years since, Ro and her husband, Griff, have separated, and the town has become essentially a ghost town, with very few but the most loyal/entrenched families left, and almost all businesses, even the health clinic where Ro worked, shut down. On this 5-year anniversary of when Sam went missing, Ro has returned to the town for a memorial with Griff and their daughter, Della, and as she is back in the place where it all happened and is going over Sam's notes and final movements for the millionth time, there are finally some hints to what might have happened, and as Della pulls at those threads, what's remaining of the old friends/families in town starts to unravel...
I really like when a mystery involves real-feeling people who I can relate to, so Ro and Griff's grief as parents, along with the relationship struggles that come with grieving differently feel true to life and worth exploring, as does the psychology of this dying town and how the loyalty to it or readiness to move on from it affects both Ro and Griff's story and the rest of the people in the town - but that's pretty much all this book is until about 200 pages in. Clearly it's a mystery what happened to Sam, but the focus is more on the grieving process, with little flashbacks/memories of Sam and other friends/family members from before his disappearance that you assume will play a part in solving this mystery but feel much more reflective than anything else. I like Jane Harper's sense of place as a character unto itself + her slow build of suspense, but while this one has the sense of place, it has very little suspense overall. Really none of the feeling of tension that I'd usually expect to pull me along, with the overall mood being much more about grief and longing for the "before". Also, I really like a mystery that peels back layers of the story and slowly reveals what characters know or remember, but there's a fine line between that and feeling like the author is deliberately withholding information as kind of an easy out. This sometimes felt a bit borderline. Overall a solid read if you are in the mood for a family drama that has a bit of procedural mystery solving to it, but not my favorite
Jane Harper book by any stretch - and she has some really excellent mysteries, if you haven't tried her yet!
★★★.75
Dissection of a Murder: Leila is a barrister who has received her first murder case - but there are a couple of twists: the victim is a well-known judge, the client is someone she worked with before and has always felt guilt about not getting him out of jail time, and, in the biggest twist of all ... the prosecutor? Her professional mentor. And her husband.
The plotting was interesting and intriguing at first, though I found the plot generally slow moving. I did like the courtroom scenes, especially learning about the British system, but when a book ends up hinging on things like deliberately withheld information, unreliable narrator, and/or total personality about-face, I end up feeling so annoyed at the end. Feels like a cop out? Perhaps mea culpa for wishing it would be a legal drama a la
Defending Jacob or
Presumed Innocent. Instead it was a legal thriller, and I did not enjoy the thriller aspects at all. In fact hated the "Witness X" interludes; from the get-go it was clear to me that a big twist was going to hinge on them, and it was deliberately obfuscating who this person was in order to make the twist - meanwhile, they felt like they had nothing to do with the actual plot.
This one is getting buzz and lots of 5-star ratings on Goodreads, but based on how it ended, I honestly felt annoyed that I had finished it. Might have liked as a Netflix series, not as a book unfortunately.
★★.75
Romance/rom-com
The MASH Up: If you're looking for something a bit unique and a lot nostalgic to read by the pool this summer, here's an idea for you: a rom-com in which a rule-following, routine-abiding accountant celebrating her 35th birthday is reminded by her best friend of a M.A.S.H. game from seventh grade in which her results predicted growing up to live in a mansion, driving a tie-dye jeep, running a roller-disco restaurant and living with 13 pet goldfish... plus her romantic match, Penn. Ruby is amused in the moment, aside from the whole Penn part. He's her twin brother's best friend from childhood, and Penn and Ruby have always had a bit of a frictional and sarcastic relationship, especially as she sees his adult lifestyle as a bit wild and irresponsible compared to her life of long-term goals and plans. But then it becomes far less amusing when she wakes up actually IN that MASH world. Experiencing a different adulthood than her real life teaches her a lot - especially as she examines how she became so much less carefree and willing to dream or try new things than she had been - and of course as her eyes are opened to these things, she also becomes more open to who Penn really is underneath their sparring.
The nostalgia factor continues as Ruby reminisces with her best friend as well as Penn about their growing up years, a timeframe that aligns with my age, and the unique factor of course comes from the magical realism but also the "breakup" portion not revolving around some dumb miscommunication but instead this alternate universe situation. I appreciated that there was just as much personal growth as romantic growth in the story, but sometimes the about-face felt a little unrealistic. I found that it lagged a bit in the middle, especially the physically flirty scenes - for me, coulda skipped some of that and still gotten the same effect of the relationship build - and the writing/characters didn't capture and charm me quite as much as my very favorite rom-coms (I often struggle with a enemies to lovers trope as the animosity can feel a little tiresome), but it was overall a fun ride and will be a great beach read when it publishes in July (I read an advance copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review).
★★★.5
Nonfiction/memoir
The Anxious Generation: Though it won't by any means make you feel good about the mental health of our teens/twenty-somethings, or about the social media landscape in general, the information in this book is invaluable and compellingly presented. The bottom line in Jonathan Haidt's argument, after he presents all of the hard data and studies that prove it in various ways: we are overprotecting our children in the real world, and we are underprotecting them in the virtual world. And as a result, the kids are not okay - in terms of anxiety/depression, as well as capacity to take on relationships and risks and new things in the real world (basically, capacity to become a full-fledged adult, I'd say), today's teens are suffering as their hours are more and more filled with phone/internet use and social media.
If I'm honest, I found the book a tad long, but that's partly because right before I read it I attended a presentation in which a local psychology professor (who has actually worked with Haidt and even more so with Jean Twenge, who is also working in this space related to teens/social media) succinctly presented the data-driven portions of the argument. And as I trusted that, I didn't need allll of the nitty gritty. But I really appreciated the concrete suggestions that Haidt brings from the data - especially no smartphones before high school and no social media before age 16 - and even more appreciated all of the insights into the importance of a play-based childhood (versus a phone/screen-based one) and the importance of giving kids more real-world freedom to roam, to have unstructured (no parent/teacher direction) time with other kids, and things like that. I also appreciated the concrete suggestions around making this happen, and especially around how we can act collectively as society and, what feels even more doable, by banding as parents of kids in a particular school/city. For starters, if we agree on some restrictions, fewer kids will have phones/social media, then our kids won't feel left out/FOMO when they're not allowed to...
In our family we already had planned to wait on these things, so an even bigger take-home for me was the portions about play-based childhood and about extending freedoms and making sure to leave plenty of time/space for unstructured in-person hangouts with peers for our middle schooler, and about thinking of the age-appropriate equivalents we can give to our preschooler. It seems like our collective mentality has moved away from these things, but individual families and schools can start the process of correcting them! Along these lines, next we're picking up
Free Range Kids (which somewhat inspired the play-based childhood portions of this book) as well as Jean Twenge's
10 Rules for Raising Kids in a High-Tech World, which has additional concrete suggestions.
★★★★★
London Falling: In late 2019, Rachelle and Matthew Brettler's 19-year-old son Zac went to stay with a friend, and when he didn't come back the next day they grew concerned and filed a police report. A few days later his body was pulled from the Thames river, and building surveillance footage was identified that showed him jumping from the balcony of the riverside luxury apartment building he had been staying in. It was an apparent suicide, but as they learned more about the life Zac had been hiding from them - that he was pretending to be the son of a Russian oligarch to these wealthy (and potentially dangerous) men was just the tip of the iceberg. This so wild it feels like it should be a movie story is then fully fleshed out with an economic history of London and how it has led to the current situation, where it is a haven to displaced oligarchs who seem to face no repercussions for any law breaking, along with a who's who in the underworld of gangsters, fraudsters, money launderers, etc.
Though I have followed his work via
The New Yorker and associated podcasts, this is the first of Patrick Radden Keefe's books that I have read, and as a typical non nonfiction reader, this is the kind of nonfiction that can get me interested! Super well researched and engaging in terms of a story arc, really well written too - but what I liked even more was the personal touch and empathy he adds. It's not just a stranger-than-fiction true crime story; it also honors the parents' confusion and grief about their son and their (rightful) frustration and anger with the police force for not thoroughly investigating, and makes them feel like the real people that they are, rather than characters to gawk at in a true crime story. And my very favorite part of the book, the final section, actually brought Patrick himself into it, as he described how he came to meet the Brettlers and how he researched for the book. It's fascinating but also has a really human and personal side that grounds this super detailed in the research yet also super big picture in the exploration of socioeconomic/crime history. Good on audio, though hard to keep track of some of the gangster people and their connections to the story - so many names and in-depth details!
★★★★
No One's Coming: This fascinating and at times jaw-dropping book tells the story of two American volunteer medical workers caught up in the incredibly deadly 2014 Ebola epidemic in Liberia, and the history and ingenuity of the aviation company that was contracted to evacuate them after they test positive for the virus and are at death's door within days. The account of the illness is harrowing, and the hurdles surmounted and red tape surmounted by the eccentric and maverick types working for Phoenix Air to plan and pull off this rescue within a matter of days is pretty amazing.
I think the author of this book set out to write page-turning narrative nonfiction, and I think he absolutely achieved it with the way he writes in short chapters, alternates between the two storylines - the health declines of Kent and Nancy in Liberia, and the rush to get an evacuation plan in place with the Phoenix crew - and keeps to just the necessary details (in contrast to the Patrick Radden Keefe book I just read, which had soooo many names to keep track of!). And he makes the main players in the story feel like quite the characters (probably not that hard to do with some of the Phoenix Air people especially, with their unique individual backgrounds). What comes along with this though is that sometimes it feels a tad melodramatic and feels like it's bordering on hero worship. Having a spouse who is a doctor, I got the sense that he found some of the medical stuff, written in a way that keeps a lay audience feeling like it's a page turner, a tad overblown, and that he thought his former pilot colleague would find some of the aviation stuff to be the same way. But there's no denying it's an engaging read and a unique topic. And even more timely in a world where epidemics/pandemics are much more in our consciousness and experience versus when this story was happening in 2014, where there's currently an active Ebola outbreak again, and where (horrifyingly, for the people who are suffering and dying because of it, and for our own health and safety in light of possible pandemic) US-AID has been dismantled and the CDC/US public health approach is a joke.
As for who I'd recommend this to - a pretty broad audience! Totally a dad book recommendation as father's day approaches, or for anyone who is into narrative nonfiction or even someone who is into medical dramas. Also probably of interest for fans of books like
Everything Is Tuberculosis or
Mountains Beyond Mountains that take an epidemiology or public health topic and give the history but also personalize it in terms of introducing us to some of the people dedicating their lives to making a difference in this area. Definitely held my attention on audio too.
★★★★.25
I've got more books from beloved authors on the docket this month - most notably Ann Patchett and David Sedaris, and I'm counting on them being more successful than this month's new releases by some of my go to authors... you know I'll report back!